410-647-7333

 Our Insurance Carriers

Choosing the right insurance can be complicated. Bay Area Insurance is proud to partner with the industry’s leading insurance companies so you can enjoy the most appropriate, affordable protection.

Accident Fund
Accident Fund

Accident Fund

Claim Phone:
866-206-5851

Policy Questions:
1-866-206-5851

Billing Phone:
1-866-206-5851

Agency Insurance Company

Claim Phone:
800-841-5241

Policy Questions:
800-492-5629

Brethren Mutual Insurance Company

Claim Phone:
800-621-4264

Policy Questions:
800-621-4264

Website URL:
https://www.bmic.com/

Chesapeake Employers Insurance Co.

Claim Phone:
1-888-410-1400

Policy Questions:
1-800-264-4943

The Cincinnati Insurance Companies

Employers Insurance Logo
Employers Insurance Logo

Employers Insurance Company

Claim Phone:
800-232-3085

Policy Questions:
888-682-6671

Foremost Insurance
Foremost Insurance

Foremost Insurance

Claim Phone:
800-527-3907

Policy Questions:
800-527-3905

Billing Phone:
800-532-4221

Great American Insurance
Great American Insurance

Great American Insurance

Claim Phone:
Please contact our office for assistance in reporting a claim.

Policy Questions:
800-221-7274

The Hartford
The Hartford

The Hartford

Claim Phone:
1-800-243-5860

Policy Questions:
860-547-5000

Billing Phone:
860-547-5000

Liberty Mutual Insurance
Liberty Mutual Insurance

Liberty Mutual

Claim Phone:
800*225-2467

Policy Questions:
888-398-8924

Billing Phone:
866-290-2920

MBG Logo
MBG Logo

Mutual Benefit Group

Claim Phone:
800-290-6361

Policy Questions:
800-283-3531

Billing Phone:
800-283-3531

Nationwide Independent
Nationwide Independent

Nationwide Independent

Claim Phone:
800-282-1446

Policy Questions:
800-532-1436

Print proof of insurance:
https://www.alliedinsurance.com

Billing Phone:
800-282-1446

Peninsula Insurance Co.

Penn Logo
Penn Logo

Penn National Insurance

Claim Phone:
800-766-2245

Policy Questions:
800-388-4764

Billing Phone:
800-766-2245

Philadelphia Insurance Logo
Philadelphia Insurance Logo

Philadelphia Insurance Companies

Claim Phone:
1-800-765-9749, ext 3

Policy Questions:
877-438-7459

Website URL:
http://www.phly.com/

Progressive
Progressive

Progressive

Claim Phone:
800-274-4499

Policy Questions:
800-776-4737

Safeco
Safeco

Safeco

Claim Phone:
800-332-3226

Policy Questions:
800-332-3226

Billing Phone:
1-888-723-3260

Selective Insurance Group
Selective Insurance Group

Selective Insurance Company

Policy Questions URL:
http://bit.ly/2bCgFH4

Billing URL:
http://bit.ly/11ta21j

State Auto

Claim Phone:
800-766- 1853

Billing Phone:
1-800-444-9950

Travelers Insurance
Travelers Insurance

Travelers

Claim Phone:
800-252-4633

Policy Questions:
(800) 842-5075

Utica National Insurance Group
Utica National Insurance Group

Utica National Insurance Group

Claim Phone:
1-800-216-1420

Policy Questions:
315-734-2000

Billing Phone:
1-800-274-1914, ext. 2333